Have We Reached the Bottom?

When I made my predictions for 2015, I knew that some of them were pretty aggressive. One in particular had the potential to be proved wrong by the end of January, and that was that the closing price of West Texas Intermediate (WTI) crude oil would not drop below $40 per barrel (bbl) in 2015.

A number of respected pundits are projecting that very outcome, with some suggesting that crude could even crash all the way to $30/bbl.

The reason I consider my prediction very aggressive is that on the day I made it the price of WTI closed at $48.80, but in each of the previous three months the price of oil had dropped at least $10/bbl. So if WTI had maintained the same downward trajectory, it could have ended January below $40/bbl.

I explained the basis of my prediction in that initial article, and then elaborated in Oil Demand Is Not Declining. In a nutshell, I don’t believe the situation in 2008 — when oil prices fell into the $30s — applies today for two reasons. First, global demand is 5 million barrels per day higher than it was in 2008. Second, most of the new oil production added in the past five years came from the shale oil fields in the U.S. Most of that production has breakeven costs above $40/bbl, which is a higher break-even than the marginal oil production from five years ago.

And a funny thing happened in January. The decline in the price of WTI was much slower than it had been during the previous five months. For the first time since September, the monthly change in the price of WTI was less than $10/bbl:

150204TELoil1
But there is a bit more to the story than that. If you look at the price changes over the past year, they trended slightly up during the first half of 2014, began to fall in the second half of June after peaking above $107/bbl and continued to decline throughout November. Following OPEC’s Nov. 27 decision not to cut export quotas the decline accelerated. It didn’t slow down until mid-January, when prices broke from the downward trend and flattened out:
150204TELoil2
So, instead of ending January below $40/bbl, WTI finished the month at $48.24, up over 7% from the previous day’s close. This increase was despite the fact that earlier in the week the Energy Information Administration (EIA) reported that U.S. crude oil stocks rose by almost 9 million barrels over the past week to reach nearly 407 million barrels, the highest level since the government began keeping records in 1982. As I write this, the price has broken back above $50/bbl.

When oil prices are plummeting, traders tend to ignore bullish news, and when they are climbing bearish news is often shrugged off. While oil could resume its decline this month and disprove my prediction by the end of February, the fact that the price of WTI rose despite news that should have sent it lower may indicate that we have reached the bottom.

(Follow Robert Rapier on Twitter, LinkedIn, or Facebook.)

Portfolio Update

Enterprise Rises to Occasion   


During the worst quarter for MLP unit prices in six years, the largest and most conservative midstream partnership of them all performed about as well as might be hoped. On Jan. 29, Enterprise Products Partners (NYSE: EPD) reported a 5% year-over-year increase in its fourth quarter gross margin and a 4% bump in distributable cash flow, good enough for 1.5x coverage on a distribution that increased 5.7% in a year’s time.

Per-unit earnings dropped as the 32% year-over-year drop in the price of natural gas liquids, which are tied to the price of crude, squeezed the variable portion of the partnership’s processing margins.

But new crude and NGL pipelines provided an offsetting lift, as part of the $4.1 billion in new fee-generating assets brought online last year.

“Global energy market is somewhere between turmoil and chaos,” the chief operating officer said on the conference call. “We have no clue how low prices may go or how long they will stay depressed, but then neither does anyone else.”

EPD’s top-notch management team has been through more than one commodity bust over the years, and the game plan remains the same: keep collecting largely fee-based margins backed by multi-year volume commitments, while hunting opportunistically for high-quality assets that might be had from distressed sellers.

For the moment, the main effect of the oil crash on EPD’s plans has been to slow its anticipated investment in new projects from $4 billion to $3.5 billion this year. That’s roughly twice the minimum required to maintain the current distribution growth pace.

But then EPD intends to keep generating one of the biggest coverage cushions in the industry so that it can continue to build out midstream infrastructure in response to a domestic drilling boom management clearly expects to continue over the long haul.

Very few other MLPs can match Enterprise’s financial flexibility, strategic assets and the scale necessary to exploit those advantages. Buy EPD below $42.50.

— Igor Greenwald

Stock Talk

Add New Comments

You must be logged in to post to Stock Talk OR create an account